The first regular Methodist Service on Kangaroo Island was held in 1836 in a carpenter’s shop in Kingscote conducted by Samuel East, a lay preacher. Over the next 50 years the development of the Methodist Church followed the fluctuations of KI’s population The first missioner was appointed in 1880. The Penneshaw Church was constructed in 1883 originally as the Methodist Wesleyan Chapel. It was constructed of corrugated iron, and was later clad in flush asbestos sheeting.
In 1885 a small chapel was erected at Cygnet River and was removed to Queenscliffe (Kingscote) in 1896 as Kingscote showed signs of growth. However, when the township stalled, the Church closed and the building became private housing.
In 1905 Mr Moses Gabb was sent to re-establish church life all over the Island, the first of several single men who battled loneliness, rough conditions and long-distances between townships as they sought to restore the Methodist Church. Through his hard work the Kingscote Chapel was re-opened in 1906 and membership increased.
In 1907 the growth in numbers led to the decision to erect a new stone Methodist Church in Kingscote. The Minister T. Ray Caust was hands on, even grubbing out stumps from the Church block. Reverend T White prepared plans, and Potters, local family builders undertook the building’s construction. It was designed in Gothic style to accommodate 200 people The foundation stone of the limestone building was laid on Monday 11 November 1907 and in a spirit of enthusiasm flags were hoisted around the town. The building was officially opened on April 19, 1908, by the SA President of the Methodist Church accompanied by visitors from Adelaide. Later the building was named Ray Caust Memorial Church in honour of the dedicated young Minister.
With no manse in Kingscote, early ministers lived in Penneshaw. Later the rear of the Church was partitioned off and provided basic accommodation. In 1937 a Manse was built next door. When a new manse was purchased the old became a centre for various church and community activities. With the formation of the Uniting Church in Australia in June 1977 the fellowship became Kingscote Uniting Church.
While aspects of Church life have changed, members haven’t changed in their desire to serve God and assist people to find meaning and purpose, acceptance, encouragement and companionship.
